Peter Safran’s previous claims of making the origin story of the Batman villain, Clayface, in a self-contained world rather than a part of the DC universe were found to be inconsistent. The story that was claimed to have never been told before and the script so good that James Gunn was convinced to make it live-action for the first time didn’t impress much.
Our Clayface 2026 review examines why the story didn’t quite land as expected while still deserving appreciation for its strengths in other areas.
Plot details of Clayface (2026)
Clayface is about Matt Hagen (played by Tom Rhys Harries), a Gotham actor hoping to make it in Hollywood. He dreams of becoming one of the biggest stars in the entertainment industry, but a misfortune hits him.
His face is disfigured by a gangster, and he turns to a scientist (Naomi Ackie) as a last resort, who accidentally transforms his body into clay.
Watch the trailer here:
Actors’ performances in Clayface (2026)
Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen was good but not as compelling. He demonstrates his acting prowess in several scenes, particularly when he starts to lose control over his body and learns about his changing appearance. However, with a missing psychological arc, his performance didn’t hit me like a truck. I couldn’t fully connect with his suffering or feel the weight of his transformation.
Naomi Ackie as Caitlyn was decent, but her performance didn’t leave the lasting impression I had hoped for. Her confusion about the experiment and its devastating consequences was evident, but the missing emotional depth didn’t add meaning to her dynamic with Matt Hagen. Consequently, the impact was nowhere to be seen due to her uneven character writing, which probably held her back.
David Dencik as Markos Szabo and Joana Ribeiro as Mia did a satisfactory job as well, though neither of their characters received enough development, but it was sufficient enough for the entire film.
What do critics add to Clayface 2026 review?
The positive critics’ consensus for Clayface explains their sentiments as:
“Carving out a unique identity for itself in the DCU while closely resembling a litany of body horror classics, Clayface takes time to get going until it eventually morphs into an icky and satisfying revenge thriller.” [Source]
Fans’ reaction
Fans are over the moon and gave a higher rating than the critics. They found the casting “perfect” and the effects “great.” The origin story worked for them, which complemented the body horror elements well. They embraced a simple narrative that remained entertaining, even if its predictability worked against it.
Is it worth watching?
It is worth watching for the reason that this is the first time ever that Batman’s one of the oldest villains has received a live-action feature. It is worth watching for the reason that James Gunn produced it and Mike Flanagan sprinkled his best flavors on top. It is worth watching for the best CGI treatment that film has undergone.
However, the film is not without flaws. The plot felt predictable, and I could not find myself emotionally invested in the story. It looked more like a Hollow Man (2000) story where the experiment takes a toll on the mental stability of the subject; however, here, Clayface wanted revenge. Shapeshifting in the blink of an eye didn’t feel convincing because, initially, when I read about the film’s news and updates on the internet, I had expected something else when I heard the term “shapeshifting.” I speculated that Matt Hagen would transform from a human into a monster, but here, his ability to take the shape of an entirely different human was something that didn’t sit quite well with me.
I could not stop myself from expecting a bit of a Batman entry at one point or another. Probably, it was because of the preconceived image of the villain and the name “Gotham City,” which activated my brain cells and imagination to picture an incoming Bat vehicle, especially toward the end, when the final grisly version of Clayface was witnessed after Caitlyn attempted to abort the experiment.
It implies that the film struggles to establish its image as a standalone entry, remaining tethered to Batman’s larger mythology, whether consciously or not. It is unable to break free from the shadow of Batman’s larger mythos. After all, a character with such a disturbing premise should be capable of carrying an entire film without the audience subconsciously waiting for Batman to show up.
One thing that actually interested me is the way Mike Flanagan extracts horror from human fears, grief, trauma, and moral failure. His horror does not solely rely on jump scares but has a deeper physical manifestation of something unresolved in human nature, as seen in The Haunting of Hill House (2018) and Midnight Mass (2021).
Clayface is the Eden Lake and Speak No Evil director’s first attempt in body horror, which is commendable in that sense. Watkins delivered Matt Hagen’s tragedy and heartbreak combined with practical as well as visual effects, a combination that made the film’s physical horror and emotional storytelling more pronounced. Still, the film feels conflicted: while its disturbing transformations are praiseworthy, the romance between the leads lacks the chemistry and shows an imbalance, thus appearing unconvincing.
What we like
- Grotesque body horror
- A tragic origin story
- James Gunn and Mike Flanagan’s involvement
- An ambitious horror approach
What could be better
- A predictable plot
- Underdeveloped character arcs
- Unconvincing romantic chemistry
- Shapeshifting that doesn’t fully convince
- A weak standalone identity
Here is a detailed breakdown of our rating for Clayface (2026):
| Story/plot | 6/10 |
| Characters and acting | 6/10 |
| Direction and pacing | 6/10 |
| Visuals and cinematography | 7/10 |
| Soundtrack/scene | 6/10 |
| Themes and message | 5/10 |
| Emotional impact | 4/10 |
| Creativity and originality | 5/10 |
| Rewatchability | 2/10 |
Our rating: 5/10
Is Clayface (2026) available for streaming?
Warner Bros. and DC Studios just released Clayface (2026) (R-rated) in theaters on October 23, 2026, and it is not available to stream at the moment.
Genre: Horror, action, crime, drama, mystery, thriller
IMDb rating: 7.6
Rotten Tomatoes: 74 percent on Tomatometer (critics’ score) and 94 percent on Popcornmeter (audience’s score)
Cast: Tom Rhys Harries, Naomi Ackie, David Dencik, Max Minghella, Eddie Marsan
Director: James Watkins
Writers: Mike Flanagan, Hossein Amini
Producers: Matt Reeves, Lynn Harris, James Gunn, Peter Safran
Release date: October 23, 2026
Movie runtime: 1 hour 48 minutes
Passionate Entertainment Writer | Trusted Pop Culture Voice
Madiha Ali is an experienced entertainment writer with over five years of expertise in covering movies, TV shows, celebrity news, and pop culture. Her bylines appear on trusted platforms like The Rolling Tape, Screen Anarchy, High on Films, Ary News, The Express Tribune, Tea and Banter, Show Snob, CelebFeedz, Snapfeedz, Daily Planet Media, The Irish Insider, and Movie Insiderz.
She brings a personal, insightful approach to every story—whether she’s analyzing the emotional layers of a film or giving her take on trending celebrity headlines. Madiha’s writing style is known for being authentic, well-researched, and reader-focused.
When she’s not writing, she’s fully immersed in the world of entertainment—watching new releases, revisiting classics, exploring behind-the-scenes content, or reading books that fuel her creativity. Her passion for storytelling drives her work and helps her stay connected to what matters most in the industry.
Madiha believes great stories start conversations, challenge perspectives, and stay with us long after the credits roll. Through her writing, she continues to share those stories with clarity, depth, and heart.
Expertise in Entertainment Journalism
Published on Trusted Media Platforms
Audience-Focused & Original Voice
Dedicated to Quality Content
